"Almost, Maine" (Portland Stage Company)
"Cariani and the rest of the ensemble, Raymond McAnally, Kathy McCafferty and Samantha Rosentrater move nimbly and animatedly through their range of characters." -Portland Phoenix
"...and Rosentrater form a quartet whose perfect timing and very present performances make the evening meaningful." -BroadwayWorld
"Rosentrater compellingly embodies Shelley's insecurities and strengths in a nuanced performance." -Broadstreet Review
"Shelley is a relatable character, beautiful delineated in the script and in Rosentrater's performance." -The Cultural Critic
"Samantha Rosentrater plays Shelley with an affecting blend of toughness and vulnerability. When she gets hurts, the audience feels that hurt acutely. She earns the audience's sympathy without ever once asking for it." -DCMetro
"Most impressive is Samantha Rosentrater as Devon. Rarely do you find an actress as natural as Rosentrater. In fact, she is so natural in the part, it's hard to tell that she's acting. Brava! - Shawangunk Journal
"...the hilariously expressive Rosentrater." -Record Online
"...delivers each of her roles with comic precision, especially her hilarious White Queen." - Cleveland Scene
"Memoirs Of A Forgotten Man"
"These actors are at the top of their game." -Sullivan County Democrat
"Peter & The Starcatcher"
"David Bardeen (Mrs. Bumbrake) and Samantha Rosentrater (Alf) were a lovely comedy duo and played opposite genders with high aplomb." -Philly Life and Culture
"As Halder's dying mother, Samantha Rosentrater gives a vivid, heart wrenching performance." -Pride Source